Broader Economy
Nepal is a poor country with significant challenges. Politically it is unstable, having recently concluded a ~15yr civil war and transitioned from monarchy to democracy. The country is primarily hills or mountains, adding significant burdens to transit times or agriculture. A 200km trip can take 7hrs. Roads are the primary means of trade, and these delays inevitably spill into higher costs for other goods.
How can we help? An improved highway from India to Kathmandu would greatly improve trade. But it would also lead to an even greater influx of people into the overcrowded Kathmandu Valley. For development, Nepal has no clear options for export. Agriculture is it's a large industry, but chiefly consumed domestically. There are few natural resources. Land is at a premium. Labour is plentiful, but that is true in it's neighbours who are at a competitive advantage thanks to their ports.
I’m a firm believe that trade improves the lot of impoverished people, but I don’t really see many good options for Nepal beyond tourism. Switzerland, Liechtenstein, Austria, and other mountainous countries may be good models. Somehow I don’t see Nepal developing a clandestine banking industry. I’ll leave broader international development to the experts :)
Healthcare
I've commented on Nepal's healthcare challenges in other posts. To recap: affordability, accessibility, misuse of anitbiotics, poor hygiene, and rampant infections are some of these. Social determinants of health such as healthy food, clean water, sanitation, and access to regular primary care are certainly a major factor in many of these challenges. The best prescription then would be a stable governement with broad based economic growth. Clearly that's idealistic :)
What is achievable then?
From my time in Nepal, the single largest factor dictating quality of care in hospitalized patients was where the attending physician trained. Doctors who had completed fellowship training within western healthcare systems generally carried the high standards of expertise from their training sites back to Nepal. Not only was their clinical knowledge and expertise improved, but through their leadership they raised the standard of care for their entire teams. I saw this carried out in cardiothoracic surgery, ICU, neurosurgery, and to a lesser extent, general surgery. Incidentally, Toronto was the most common fellowship location.
Why don't all Nepali doctors do international fellows then? A Nepali doctor needs to pass the Canadian licensing exams, apply, be accepted to the program, secure a visa into Canada, pay live in an expensive foreign country, and pay tuition. Even in cases where their tuition is covered and a stipend paid, the other tasks represent a non-trivial burden. The Candian exams alone could run $2000, assuming both passed first time. Nepali doctors may save for several years to be able to afford to train abroad. Fully sponsored fellowships would help dramatically with reducing this burden and improving the quality of care delivered in Nepal.
*Selection bias may be occuring - the best doctors in Nepal secure the foreign fellowships. While possibly true, my experience and observations suggest the incremental benefit is still worthwhile.
What about dedicated training missions where Canadian clinicians visit Nepal for education?
I think there is definitely a role for these. They allow instruction to a large number of local clinicians, but are hindered by the immersion in the local culture. Reinforcement of practices such as handwashing would be difficult in a culture that does not value it.
Anything other than trianing?
Beyond training financial support of organizations such as NCCDF will allow incremental improvements to care, while making it more affordable for the poor. There are other comparable organizations with their own specific niches including cardiac surgery, and ophthalmology. Ideally the government will stabilize and healthcare be improved centrally, but this is likely to take decades to see real change.
What about equipment donations? If the equipment is coordinated with clinicians in Nepal, there can be a significant benefit to equipment donations. I was able to advance NCCDF's cause by bringing ventilator related equipment with me. Regrettably the Nepali government restricts importation of technology intensive devices such as patient monitors. When I left though, the surgery team at TUTH was anticipating receipt of >$400000 of refurbished equipment including laparoscopic towers and instruments. I don't know the exact breakdown of cost to TUTH vs donations pertaining to it. Generally equipment needs to be high value as a shipping crate costs ~$20000 to deliver from North America to Nepal. Matching equipment to the needs is important. This is well documented in other posts pertaining to disaster relief and international development.. In short, cash donatiosn to the appropriate organization is usually best.
What about equipment donations? If the equipment is coordinated with clinicians in Nepal, there can be a significant benefit to equipment donations. I was able to advance NCCDF's cause by bringing ventilator related equipment with me. Regrettably the Nepali government restricts importation of technology intensive devices such as patient monitors. When I left though, the surgery team at TUTH was anticipating receipt of >$400000 of refurbished equipment including laparoscopic towers and instruments. I don't know the exact breakdown of cost to TUTH vs donations pertaining to it. Generally equipment needs to be high value as a shipping crate costs ~$20000 to deliver from North America to Nepal. Matching equipment to the needs is important. This is well documented in other posts pertaining to disaster relief and international development.. In short, cash donatiosn to the appropriate organization is usually best.
How will I be helping?
Going forward I hope to maintain ties to NCCDF and help them through advocacy, technical support, and donations from Canada. I also hope to maintain ties to global health in my residency, and to advocate for the creation of sponsored fellowship opportunities. And hopefully someday I will go abroad to provide healthcare to the needy while teaching the local doctors. Time will tell.
Fin
Thanks for reading! This is my last blog post related to Nepal. I'm not sure I'll continue blogging. Time will tell :). Travel, healthcare, technology, and politics are likely topics if I do continue (in that order too!). Happy travels! And remember to follow your heart! :)